Subscribers iconSite access
Newsletter signup



home subscribe

Community Q&A forum

Print
Email
Text size
Comment

Disappearing trust 

Answered by Keiron Root
15 August 2008 [0 comments]

Q: 

I wish to draw your attention to the ‘Resources Investment Trust’, which is listed in What Investment in the sector entitled ‘Specialist: Liquidity’.  In fact, this trust should be in the sector entitled ‘Specialist: Commodities & Natural Resources.
The trust was correctly listed in ‘Specialist: Commodities & Natural Resources’ up to and including August 2007, issue 293, but in the next issue, September 2007, it had been moved to ‘Specialist: Liquidity’.
Also, the performance figures in issue 302 of What Investment, May 2008, for the Resources Investment Trust appear to be somewhat excessive – far outperforming the Merrill Lynch World Mining Trust. Are you certain that these figures are accurate? The reason I query the figures is because I have seen performance figures for these trusts in
other publications where the Resources Investment Trust mostly underperforms the
Merrill Lynch World Mining Trust.
Derek Crawford
Via email

A: 

Keiron Root replies:
Resources IT is not a member of the AIC and, therefore, does not appear in their ‘official’ sectors; but it was customary to compare it with other commodity and natural resources funds.
However, this fund is currently in the process of being wound up. At an EGM in October 2007, its shareholders instructed the board of Resources Investment Trust to ‘take action to realise the Company’s investments as soon as practicable, so as to put the Company in a position to return cash to shareholders, by way of share buybacks and/or the liquidation of the company as soon as reasonably practicable’ and modified the investment policies of the Company accordingly. The company’s articles were subsequently amended to require that a general meeting of the company be convened for a date not later than 31 March 2008, ‘at which a special resolution should be proposed for the company to be wound up voluntarily’.

This duly happened and the EGM on 31 March approved the winding up of the company and the cancellation of its ordinary shares on 31 March 2009.

As a consequence, its shares are suspended while distribution of its assets takes place. I presume that is why it is now classed as a ‘Liquidity’ fund and also explains the exceptionally high total return figure, which assumes that these large distributions are reinvested in the trust’s shares, even though it is not possible to do this in reality. This invariably happens with trusts that are winding up and distributing their assets.

The figures shown in our performance tables are intended to give an indication of total return over specified periods (i.e. with income reinvested) as this enables comparison between different types of funds – those targeting income with those targeting capital growth, for example. Unfortunately, because all funds are treated the same way, this means that distributions of the proceeds of trusts that are being wound up, as in this case, are automatically shown as being reinvested, giving rise to some fantastically large performance numbers!

There are currently no comments on this post.

 
Other questions answered by Keiron Root

Advertisement

Q&A  More Q&A forumspacerQ&AAsk a question

Stopping the losses

13 September 2008 [0 comments]

Q: 

I have a small portfolio of investment trusts, which I trade fairly actively. I do use some charting to help stock purchase timing, but I’m having trouble determining a satisfactory ‘stop-loss’ strategy. I have set ‘trailing stop-losses’ but seem to either sell too early as a result of a small perturbation or sell at, or very close to, the bottom of a larger correction. Is there any technique I should be using? Any suggestions would be very much appreciated.

P Perry,
Via e-mail

 
 

Recommendations Recommendations

 
unlock
unlock
moreAsset Monitor
29 September 2009
unlock
moreFund Watch
10 September 2009
unlock
 
 

Q&A Investors' blog

VIDEO: How women can make the most of their pension savings

12 March 2010 [0 comments]

Alison Morris, savings expert at Scottish Widows, highlights the difference between men and women’s pensions and what women should be doing to make sure they retire with a healthy pension.

VIDEO: Advice for pension savers

11 March 2010 [0 comments]

Alison Morris, savings expert at Scottish Widows, provides advice to consumers on pensions and highlights that Brits are simply not saving enough.

VIDEO: Top ISA tips

10 March 2010 [0 comments]

Andy Parsons, Advice team manager at The Share Centre explains the current ISA allowance situation and recommends funds that investors may wish to consider for their ISAs.

 
 

Q&A Events

 
 

Top ten  Top Ten Life Funds

Fund Offer 1y 3y 5y
UBS Life Structured Credit A 85.39 230.1 n/a n/a
Skandia Finland FIM Russia 11.36 185.6 -3.8 79.2
Skandia Finland JPM New European 1.96 140.9 -9.1 n/a
Canlife SVM UK Opportunities LS4 Acc 103.40 133.4 -13.8 35.5
Skandia Finland Alfred Berg Ryssland 0.86 132.8 n/a n/a
AXA JPM New Europe 193.80 132.1 n/a n/a
Zurich Sterling JPM New Europe 258.80 130.6 n/a n/a
L&G SVM UK Opportunities 100.32 130.0 -16.4 n/a
Skandia JPM New Europe 253.10 128.8 18.2 98.1
Merch Inv Sanlam Global Financial S6 106.50 126.4 n/a n/a