Unit trusts vs investment trusts
Q:
I want to invest a modest monthly sum for my two grandchildren aged three and seven years old, with a view to helping them with college fees when the time comes. What are the relative merits of using unit trusts and investment trusts to achieve this?
The company I deal with only mentions unit trusts in its promotional material, although it says it is possible to purchase investment trusts from it. Does it concentrate on unit trusts because there is more commission or are there good reasons for favouring this type of investment?
JM Weekes, Exmouth
A:
Assuming you will be looking to invest until your grandchildren are, say, 18 or 21 years old, either share-backed unit trusts or investment trusts should produce a good return – although not without some fluctuations on the way. Also, as a grandparent you should not be caught out by the income tax consequences or mooted capital gains tax consequences of parents saving for children. These payments may actually fall into your inheritance tax (IHT) allowance, making them IHT-free.
Share-backed unit trusts and investment trusts should offer broadly similar investment characteristics. However, some crude comparisons between the two would be:
• Investment trusts are potentially more volatile because, being closed-ended and traded on the stock exchange, the share price can trade at a premium or, more likely, a discount to the net asset value. The share price will fluctuate as they move in and out of favour.
• In theory, if you buy an investment trust at a discount you get an income stream magnified by the discount factor.
• Unit trusts are generally easier to buy, especially using small, regular contributions. They are also available through fund supermarkets, such as Fidelity’s FundsNetwork, Skandia and Cofunds, while investment trusts generally are not. Using fund supermarkets opens the possibility of using several funds from different investment houses, fund diversification, asset allocation, low-cost switching and so on.
• Some investment trust companies do run their own regular contribution schemes, but you would normally have to go direct to that company.
• Unit trusts usually pay the adviser commission; investment trusts normally do not.
There are currently no comments on this post.
Advertisement
More Q&A forum
Ask a question
Sector confusion
27 September 2008 [0 comments]Q:
Could you please advise me where you are now placing Jupiter Emerging European Opportunities in the monthly tables of Unit Trust Performance.
It seems to have disappeared!
Christopher Chalker,
Via e-mail
- Stopping the losses 13 September 2008 [0 comments]
- Repayment dilemma 6 September 2008 [0 comments]
- Suspended animation 22 August 2008 [0 comments]
- Disappearing trust 15 August 2008 [0 comments]
- The limitations of nominees 8 August 2008 [0 comments]
Recommendations
Investors' blog
Trading through the Fall
28 November 2008 [0 comments]Angus Rigby, chief executive officer of TD Waterhouse, reflects on retail trading activity in September
Spotlight on…… Bond Funds
28 November 2008 [0 comments]Andrew Merricks searches for a safe haven in the storm
Sell euphoria, Buy despair
27 November 2008 [0 comments]Terry Bond recognises that there are attractive opportunities out there, for those with cash to invest
Events
Top 10 Inv Trusts, 1yr%
| Prospect Japan Li... | +40.2 | ||
| Genesis Malaysia Maju | +31.7 | ||
| JP Morgan Private... | +25.9 | ||
| Ruffer Investment... | +10.5 | ||
| Smaller Companies... | +8.1 | ||
| Investec High Inc... | +6.7 | ||
| Ecofin Water & Po... | +6.7 | ||
| Jupiter Second Sp... | +6.3 | ||
| JP Morgan Income ... | +5.9 | ||
| JZ Capital Partners | +5.7 | ||

