Q&A Forum
The limitations of nominees
Q:
Having read various pieces in your magazine at different times regarding the merits and demerits of certificated and nominee share dealing, it seems to me that certain advantages of holding certificates have been missed.
Indeed, I recently attended an Alliance Trust Roadshow and sat on a ‘shareholder club’ discussion group, where I was amazed to find, among a fairly sophisticated bunch of investors, such a lack of appreciation as to the shareholder rights one loses with a nominee account.
As an extra thread, I also recently attended the AGM of an investment trust in Edinburgh. As a trustee to my grandchildren’s funds, my name was missing from the list at reception. I was told that I was welcome to the meeting as long as I didn’t participate in the voting.
I was further informed that had I informed the plan managers of the trusts beforehand, I could have voted. It occurred to me that nominee shareholders may well find that if they feel strongly about an issue, they might be able to exercise their voting rights in a similar way. I would be interested in your panel’s thoughts on this subject.
Bev Wilkinson
via email
- Pension boost 4 February 2008 [0 comments]
- AIM stocks 4 February 2008 [0 comments]
- Pension restrictions 29 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Best use of resources? 29 October 2007 [2 comments]
- Income portfolio 29 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Protecting your retirement assets 29 October 2007 [0 comments]
- An inconvenient restriction 1 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Concentrating on returns 1 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Money Clinic - An inconvenient restriction 1 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Market timing 1 October 2007 [0 comments]
- Advice planning 13 September 2007 [0 comments]
- Junior options 13 September 2007 [0 comments]
- Care funding 13 September 2007 [0 comments]
- Diversification matters 13 September 2007 [0 comments]
- Taxing thoughts 13 September 2007 [0 comments]
Q&A Experts
Donna Bradshaw, financial planning strategist at IFG GroupDonna started her career in financial services in 1987, working in pensions for Standard Life. Donna now works with IFG Group, a financial services group with operations in UK, Republic of Ireland and other countries throughout the world, as financial planning strategist.
Alison Cashmore is Communications Manager at TD Waterhouse, one of the UK's largest brokers. During a 12-year career in financial services she has been responsible for marketing and communications for a number of execution-only brokers, and has been with TD Waterhouse since 2002.
Angus Rigby, chief executive officer, TD Waterhouse UK:Angus was appointed chief executive of TD Waterhouse UK in 2006, having previously held the position of Chief Operating Officer. Prior to this, Angus was joint managing director of offshore broker Internaxx, a joint venture between TD Waterhouse and Fortis in Luxembourg.
Paul Duckworth, chartered financial planner:A chartered financial planner and Fellow of the Personal Finance Society, Paul is also one of the most highly qualified financial advisers in the UK. He runs his own fee-based practice specialising in sophisticated financial planning for wealthy individuals.
Keiron Root, editor of What Investment:Keiron Root has been a financial journalist for 21 years. Currently editor of What Investment, he joined the title in April 1989, and has held a senior editorial position since January 1990. At various times he has also written regular investment columns for The Independent and GQ magazine.
Leonie Kerswill, tax partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers:Leonie is the tax partner responsible for leading the London private client business within PwC. The clients she has responsibility for include shareholders and senior management of private companies, entrepreneurs and wealthy families.
Jonathan Davis, chartered financial planner at Armstrong Davis:Jonathan Davis BA MBA FCII AIFP FPFS is a chartered financial planner and the managing director of a small independent and impartial financial advice firm based in The City of London, with an office on the Herts / Essex border.
Andrew Merricks, head of investments at Skerritt Consultants:Andrew has been in financial Services for 18 years. He regularly appears in the trade and national press, as well as on TV and Radio, commenting on investment-related issues. Andrew is also the author of The Money Doctor, a monthly column for What Investment
With over 15 years experience of specialising in and advising on long-term care funding, Philip has been a regular contributor to professional journals, National press articles and TV and radio broadcasts.
Janet Davies, managing director of Symponia:Beginning her 15-year career in financial services as a direct sales adviser for PPP Lifetime Care in 1992, Janet became a specialist IFA in the field of care fees planning in 1999. She became head of care fees planning at Warwick Butchart in 2003. She established her own care fees planning specialist business, Symponia, in January 2005.
Phil Verity, Partner at MazarsPhil Verity is a Partner at Mazars, the international accounting and business advisory firm, and Head of the Mid Corporate Market business line. Phil works with a wide variety of entrepreneurial and owner-managed businesses, helping them tackle the challenges of growth and development.
Ask a question
- Ask a question [12 answered questions in the forum]
Please use this area as an opportunity to ask our 13 industry experts a variety of questions relating to personal investments. You can also comment on the experts answers and on related content throughout the site.
Events
Investors'
blog
Market Insider: Sunset Boulevard 8 August 2008 [0 comments]
Michael Wilson suggests that Japan is in poor condition to face the current global economic crisis
Something for everyone 4 August 2008 [0 comments]
Keiron Root considers the range of services provided by private client stockbrokers and investment managers
Getting the basics right 31 July 2008 [0 comments]
What Investment catches up with The Share Centre to find out how investment clubs can benefit from the services provided by their advisers
Recommendations
Advertisement
Top 10 Life Funds, 3yr%
| SKANDIA BLACKROCK... | +119.9 | ||
| ZURICH LATIN AMER... | +111.1 | ||
| ZURICH LATIN AMER... | +110.8 | ||
| NU GARTMORE CHINA... | +90.0 | ||
| WINTERTHUR BLACKR... | +84.5 | ||
| SKANDIA INVESCO P... | +83.8 | ||
| SKANDIA THREADNEE... | +83.3 | ||
| AXA GARTMORE CHIN... | +82.7 | ||
| AIG MERRILL LYNCH... | +78.0 | ||
| SKANDIA GARTMORE ... | +77.6 | ||
Advertisement
Safe, stable, tax-free returnsThe latest 12 month figures show the Fine Wine 100 Index up 57%. Safe, stable, tax-free returns in a volatile economic climate. For a free information pack click here.
Our crystal-clear, commission-free trading enables you to profit irrespective of whether the markets are up or down. Spread bet on a range of indices, currencies, commodities and options; plus thousands of individual shares. Open an account.


Change: